Pakistan Cricket is clueless


April 1, 2015 by McDowski

According to ESPNcricinfo, the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has decided to appoint Azhar Ali as the new captain for the ODI team, replacing the retired Misbah-ul-Haq.

This is simply a bad decision.

In a twist of irony, the other day I was discussing the future of Pakistan cricket with my friends. I mentioned how it was most important that Pakistan change their old tactics, forget about the cliched we-need-a-calm-stable-batsman-in-the-middle-order and get with aggressive. This wasn’t really rocket science. The sport of cricket has changed significantly since Pakistan’s heyday in the 90s. Just look at the four teams that made the World Cup final – South Africa, Australia, New Zealand and India. You know what they have in common? All of them have an aggressive and attacking approach to the game. Misbah, Younis Khan… Pakistan’s middle order was a relic of the old days of cricket. What Pakistan needs to do, more than anything, is adapt to the modern game. Change their entire approach, and start anew from the ground up, construct a team that fits in with the demands of the sport. And that starts with appointing an appropriate captain.

My friend argued that they should re-instate Shoaib Malik. I argued that Malik hadn’t played in a long time, and besides, Pakistan cricket needed to just blow itself up and start fresh. And that meant not repeatedly going back to the same old people.

So, of course, the very next day after my conversation with my friends, the PCB decides that Azhar Ali will be the new captain. A Test match specialist batsman, someone wholly unsuited to the modern ODI format, and someone who has only played a grand total of 14 ODIs in his entire career. In fact, he hasn’t even played a single ODI since January 2013. That’s over two years without ODI experience, from a batsman who clearly never fit into the format to begin with. Of course PCB thinks he should be the new captain. The folly of this decision is shocking. Instead of adapting to the modern (i.e. attacking) game of cricket, PCB has decided to go completely the other way and make the team even more defensive, inevitably digging the team deeper inside their cramped hole.

Even Malik would have been a better choice than this. He, like Ali, hasn’t played an ODI in two years. Unlike Ali, however, Malik was suited to the ODI game. Unlike Ali, Malik does have a fair amount of ODI experience. Most importantly – unlike Ali, Malik actually has captained the team before. And he did a pretty decent job, too. You’re not going to find any odes written to his stint, but the result were actually impressive. In the 36 ODIs that Malik was captain, Pakistan was victorious 24 times. In fact, in terms of win percentage, of all the ODI captains that Pakistan has ever had, Malik’s rate of 66.7% ranks right at the top. I still stand by my original argument for not looking to the past, but, man! Malik would have been a better choice than Ali.

What disappoints me almost as much as the decision, if not more, is the reaction of Pakistan’s fans on the article’s comment section. The majority actually seemed pleased! Lauding the PCB for going with a “level-headed” player. It’s unbelievable. The fans are as clueless as the Board, convincing themselves that a ‘safe’ choice is the right choice.

Maybe the decision was good, after all. Not because Pakistan will have success under the captaincy of Azhar Ali, because they surely won’t. But only because, perhaps, this is the selection we deserve.

Welcome to the next few years of mediocrity.


2 thoughts on “Pakistan Cricket is clueless

  1. Amir Mir says:

    I agree that Azhar Ali should not have been appointed captain, but I think the decision to appoint him speaks volumes of where Pakistan currently is. Unfortunately, Pakistan cricket has no-one they can turn to, the younger talent is not delivering and the experienced are as useless as the in-experienced. But, one thing is for sure Pakistan simply cannot go back to selecting, re-selecting (x50) has been players such as Younis, Malik, K.Akmal etc… They should just do what WI’s have done, give the captaincy to a younger player- at the end of the day you have nothing to lose, as you are not gaining anything as it is. Ultra-attack is the mind-set today, but Pakistan are still stuck in defensive reverse- the reasons why Misbah was so cautious, he didn’t trust his batsman. Pakistan have no consistent, reliable batsman and they will find out now how much they will suffer.

    • McDowski says:

      Oh, I agree. Pakistan definitely needs to look to young blood, rather than revisiting the past.

      The only reason I mentioned the Malik thing was to contrast with Azhar’s selection. I definitely agree that Pakistan needs more quality, trustworthy, and attacking batsmen to have any hope of challenging the top teams in cricket.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Escaped to:

A History of Rambling

Member of The Internet Defense League

Don’t hate me just because I’m right. | Hang Time Blog

The official news blog of with commentary and analysis from's staff of writers.

Carly Watters, Literary Agent Blog

On publishing, clients, writing, and queries


All Things Tech

The Grimdark Review

The very best of fantasy.

Leona's Blog of Shadows

Book reviews and writing related stuff

Thoughts on the latest to weigh down my bookshelves.

Apprentice Alf’s Blog

Everything you ever wanted to know about DRM and ebooks, but were afraid to ask.

%d bloggers like this: